Ottawa Office

614 N. Perry, St. Rt. 65

P.O. Box 364

Ottawa, OH 45875

Bluffton Office

115 N. Main St.

Bluffton, OH 45817




Office Hours

Monday - Friday: 8:00a.m - 5:00p.m.

Evenings and Weekends:  By Appt.

Insurance Solutions | Ottawa, OH | Fortman Insurance Services 800-686-4500 Annissa Hoyt 10583559 Betty Wagner Nancy Scalf Tammy Evans Marla Santomieri Amy Baker Laurie Basinger Zack Fortman Jonathan Fortman Catherine Fortman no Glasses John Fortman

Meet our dedicated Team!

The right insurance agent can make all the difference in helping you get the insurance coverage you deserve.


Whether you are looking for an Individual Medical or Group Medical Insurance plan OR a policy for your Home or Vehicles, our agents will help you find the right one for you! Call, stop, or email us TODAY!

Contact any of our agents below!

You, your family, and your business deserve the absolute best. No matter what you're seeking, we have the right tools to provide the coverage you deserve.

Contact us today for your

FREE insurance quote!


Thank you for allowing our family business to assist you since 1978!

John Fortman — Co-Founder

Property & Casualty


John started Fortman Insurance in the fall of 1978 by obtaining a license in Health & Life Insurance and began writing Life Insurance.  A bit further down the road, he acquired his Property & Casualty License and started to represent Property & Casualty Insurance Companies. His wife, Catherine, joined him in the business in 1982, and they are proud that they have built their business from scratch and are now at 14 employees – and two locations, Ottawa and Bluffton, Ohio. Their agency has been a member of the Professional Insurance Association and the Big I Independent Insurance Association. Their agency is licensed with over 50 different insurance companies to serve your needs. In John's free time, he plays a variety of sports, including racquetball and bicycling, and also enjoys traveling. He can be contacted at 419-523-4500 Ext. 622 or jkfortman@fortmanins.com

Catherine Fortman — Co-Founder

Individual & Group Medical Benefits, Medicare and Ancillary Coverages


Catherine is licensed in both Property & Casualty and Health & Life.  She joined her husband, John Fortman, in the business in 1982. Catherine has been a member of the Health Underwriters Association for many years. John and Catherine also have a daughter, Shalynn, who lives in Fort Lauderdale, FL, with her husband, David Loudenslager. Catherine graduated from International Business College in Fort Wayne, IN.  She also has five years of clerical and banking experience from City Loan and Savings, with the last two of those five years, as a Financial Service Rep for the bank. In her free time, she enjoys walking, jogging, kayaking, reading and traveling. Contact Catherine at 567-242-8291 or email her at cfortman@fortmanins.com

Amy Baker

Property & Casualty


Amy has been in the insurance industry since 1994. She joined the Fortman Insurance team in 2005 and specializes in Property & Casualty Insurance. Amy graduated from Holgate High School. She resides in Ottawa with her husband, Brian, and they have four children. They enjoy camping and watching the Ohio State Buckeyes. Amy is a member of the Holgate United Methodist Church and is a leader of the Youth Group. You can contact Amy at 419-358-4600 Ext. 625 or email her at abaker@fortmanins.com




Jonathan Fortman — Owner

Individual & Group Medical Benefits and Ancillary Coverages


Jonathan has been an Ohio Native his entire life, born in Ottawa, OH, and graduated from Ottawa-Glandorf High School in 1999. He then attended Bowling Green State University, where he graduated in December 2002 with a Bachelor’s Degree in Economics. Upon graduation of college, Jonathan started in the family business in January of 2003. He is a Licensed Health & Life Agent, with a focus on Group and Individual Health and Ancillary Benefits. Jonathan has become an expert in the field of employee benefits and helping business owners find affordable health and ancillary coverages. He married  Branden Fortman on April 18, 2009, and they have a son, Fischer Michael Fortman. Jonathan is excited to continue on the success of Fortman Insurance by making sure that our customers' satisfaction is at the heart of every work day. If you need to contact Jonathan Fortman for your heath, life, and ancillary coverage insurance needs, you can reach him at 419-523-4500 Ext. 624 or jfortman@fortmanins.com


Annissa Hoyt

Property & Casualty, Claims


Annissa joined the Fortman Insurance team in April of 2016 and became a licensed agent in July of 2017.  She is a native of Huron, OH, where she graduated from Huron High School in 1989. She worked with Allstate insurance in the claims processing and CAT divisions. Annissa has spent most of her career in the medical field, specializing in bariatric rehabilitation and hospice care. She and her husband Don, reside in Columbus Grove. They have three sons, Logan, Austin and Lance, who have blessed them with three beautiful grandchildren. Annissa enjoys music, hunting, the outdoors, playing the piano and spending time with her family. You can contact Annissa at 419-523-4500 Ext. 634 or by email at ahoyt@fortmanins.com

Marla Santomieri

Property & Casualty


Marla has worked in the insurance industry for almost 30 years, specializing in Property and Casualty.  She joined Fortman Insurance Services in September, 2013 and works in the Bluffton office as a licensed agent providing customer service for home, auto, farm and commercial policies.  Marla lives in the Bluffton area with her husband, Eric. They have two children and five grandchildren. In her spare time, she enjoys spending time with family and friends, Ohio State football and watching movies. She can be contacted at 419-358-4600 Ext. 605 or email her at msantomieri@fortmanins.com

Tammy Evans

Individual Medical Benefits


After four years as an Assistant Director at the Ottawa Senior Center, Tammy joined the Fortman Insurance Team in March 2014.  Tammy has a Bachelor of Arts degree from Bowling Green State University and a Secondary Teaching Credential from California State University, San Marcos. She is a former journalist for the Putnam County Sentinel and Lima News and also has worked as an editor and English teacher. In her free time, she enjoys nature and walking. You may contact Tammy at 419-358-4600 Ext. 623 or email her at tevans@fortmanins.com

419-523-4500 (Ottawa)

800-686-4500 (Ottawa)

419-358-4600 (Bluffton)



Our two sons are the new owners of

Fortman Insurance Services

as of July 1, 2015

Jonathan Fortman

and Zachary Fortman

Nancy Scalf

Property & Casualty


Nancy has been in the insurance industry since 2001. She joined the Fortman Insurance team in 2015 and specializes in Property & Casualty, Commercial and Farm Insurance. Nancy is a graduate of Delphos St John’s, University of Northwestern Ohio with an Associate Degree in Business and currently working on a Bachelor Degree.  She has earned her Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) designation, giving her the tools to make customer service a priority.   Nancy resides in Delphos with her husband Kevin. They have three daughters Christin, Abby, Molly and two grandchildren Wesley and Lily. She enjoys spending her time with her family and grandchildren.  She also enjoys gardening, baking, watching Hockey and College Football, especially University of Michigan. She is a member of Delphos St John’s Catholic Church. Contact Nancy at 419-523-4500 Ext. 632 or email her at nscalf@fortmanins.com

Betty Wagner

Property & Casualty


Betty has been a licensed Property and Casualty agent since 2003. She joined the Fortman Insurance team in 2015. Betty graduated from Ayersville High School. She spent six (6) years foster parenting special needs children. She resides in Ottoville with her husband, Dan. They have two children and have been blessed with two grandchildren. They enjoy traveling and attending Ohio State Buckeyes football games. Contact Betty at 419-523-4500 Ext. 633 or email her at bwagner@fortmanins.com

Megan Hohman 2

Megan Hohman


Megan Hohman joined Fortman Insurance in November 2015.  Megan is a licensed agent in Life & Health. Before coming to Fortman Insurance Megan worked for American Income specializing in Life insurance. Megan resides in Ottawa with her fiancée, John,  and three children Jenna, Emily, and Cara. She enjoys camping, swimming, and spending time with her family. You can contact Megan at  419-523-4500 Ext. 603 or email her at mhohman@fortmanins.com

Marya Danaher


Marya Danaher joined Fortman Insurance in November 2016.  Marya is a licensed agent in Life & Health. Before coming to Fortman Insurance, Marya worked for American Income specializing in Life insurance. Marya moved to Wapakoneta in 2012 from Rochester, Michigan. Marya is married to Sean Danaher, and has a stepson- Evan. Marya is also a Beachbody coach and enjoys running, singing, cooking and watching hockey and football with her family especially the Michigan State Spartans. You can contact Marya at 419-523-4500 EXT 627 or email her at mdanaher@fortmanins.com

Marya Danaher Beth Siefker Beth Siefker Beth Siefker Beth Siefker Beth Siefker

Beth Siefker


Beth Siefker joined Fortman Insurance in November of 2017, as a licensed Property & Casualty agent. Beth is an independent agent for Guide One, specializing in Church and Non-profit Insurance. Beth has been integral in building multiple businesses over the past 20 years. She is looking forward to servicing the needs of the Church and non-profit sector with a product that best suits their insurance needs. Beth resides in Leipsic with her husband Randy and their three children. She cherishes family time and being involved in the community. You can contact Beth directly at

419-236-1649 or email her at bsiefker@fortmanins.com